
Truly great classic cocktails not only survive the test of time, they also inspire countless tweaks, riffs and reimaginings on the original. When it comes to creating a new cocktail, working off a classic formula is one of the best ways to work. With that in mind, if creating your own recipes is something you’re getting into, make sure to read our article ‘How to Create a New Cocktail Recipe’ for some handy tips on how to create great recipes of your own.
While we built Candra to guide you through cocktail culture, we also like to be part of moving cocktail culture forward too. That’s why we write and develop new recipes, not just teach the classics and write about the modern popular recipes. With that in mind, this whisky month we thought it’d be a good time to share some of our favourite reworked whisky classics.
Whiskey Highball Family
Still think it’s just a whisky soda? Well, read this – ‘Cocktail 101 : Whiskey Highball’ and then go and make a classic Whisk(e)y Highball, and see how you feel. OK, sure it IS a whiskey soda, BUT made into an art form. It truly is one of the best ways to enjoy your favourite tipple. Now try these two versions of ours that add a hint of fruit to your Highball.
1. Apple of My Rye
A delicious twist on the classic Whisky Highball originally written for our cocktail book, How to ‘Make Better Cocktails’. The recipe features the addition of apple brandy and a splash of apple juice to perfectly complement the spicy notes of Rye Whisky. Long, dry and refreshing, we think that this is a great addition to the Highball canon.
2. Peach Honey Highball
The clue’s in the title here. Peach, honey, and Irish whiskey come together with a splash of citrus and of course, lashings of crisp sparking water.
You could argue that it’s a type of Whisky Collins I guess, but we’d suggest that the emphasis on the sparkling water in the balance of the recipe keeps it just about in the Highball category.. What really matters is that it’s delicious. These are tried and tested flavours that partner so well with whiskey, in a tall and refreshing combination. The balance of the recipe shows off all the flavours you’d expect, but whilst still being light and refreshing and not sweet and overly fruity.
Manhattan Family
One of the most famous classic cocktails of all time. The Manhattan has inspired variations that are themselves famous classics in their own rights. At its heart, the Manhattan is a simple three ingredient, booze forward cocktail, that’s served ‘up’. American Whisky, traditionally Rye, stirred with bitters and sweet vermouth. Such an elegantly simple format leaves a lot of room for invention and creativity. So with that in mind, here are four of our favourite Manhattan twists.
3. Brooklyn Blanc
The Brooklyn is one of the most famous Manhattan variations, and our take on it is only a minor tweak on the original. However we’d argue the little changes are for the better. As you might guess from the name, the key difference here is the replacement of dry vermouth with a Blanc or Bianco vermouth (or Lillet Blanc would work too).. This slightly sweeter style of vermouth plays more easily with the whisky and gives the drink a fuller body.
Secondly, Nonino Amaro replaces Amer Picon from the original recipe. Nonino is light and delicate, allowing the other ingredients to sing, a perfect alternative to Amer Picon. This is particularly helpful in the US where Amer Picon isn’t even available.
4. El Porto
The El Porto is another Manhattan variation created IN Manhattan. This time however, we’re talking Manhattan Beach California, not New York, and our living room, not a cocktail bar.
The bittersweet combination of coffee and Campari, along with traditional ingredients of rye whisky and sweet vermouth build depth of flavour with a light bitter finish, to deliver a very tasty variation.
5. Toasted Manhattan
This batched Manhattan twist is perfect for entertaining, as the drink is made and bottled ready to serve straight from the fridge. Your preferred choice of American whisky and sweet vermouth are combined with the perfect amount of water for dilution. This combination is then infused with soba-cha (toasted buckwheat) to add a delicious toasted cereal note.
Once infused, the soba-cha is filtered out and the drink re-bottled. All that needs to be done is to make the bottle very cold then pour it into your favourite cocktail glass with a twist of lemon.
6. Red Hook Café
Our second twist with a hint of coffee. Like the Brooklyn Blanc, this is also a twist on a twist. The subtle but important difference is that the bitter element in the original is replaced with coffee liqueur.
The classic Red Hook is made with Punt e Mes, a product that is essentially a hybrid of sweet vermouth and amaro. The name is a clue, as it is translated as Point and a Half; one part sweet vermouth and half a part of bitter.
Our version keeps that ratio, but combines sweet vermouth with coffee liqueur. This creates a delicious new take on the Red Hook, but also makes it a little more accessible for most to make, as Punt a Mes can be harder to come by than sweet vermouth and coffee liqueur. No shade on Punt e Mes, grab a bottle and try the classic too, but the Red Hook Café is a great addition to the Manhattan canon.
Old Fashioned Family
The Old Fashioned follows the original definition of what a cocktail is; spirit, water, sugar and bitters. Like the Highball and the Manhattan, simplicity is not a weakness, it’s a strength. A clear roadmap from which an almost infinite number of variations can be born.
When creating a new variation, you can play with every one of the elements, including the spirit of course. You can request a Mezcal Old Fashioned in any cocktail bar these days without even raising an eyebrow. We have a delicious rum and a marmalade version on Candra that you should definitely try too. However, we’re talking whisky cocktails here, so below we’ve kept strictly to our favourite whisky based Old Fashioned creations, but fear not, there’s still plenty of variety for you to choose from.
7. Irish American Old Fashioned
The Old Fashioned is made with all and every variety of whisky these days. In this bottled version we combined the best of North America with delicious Irish Whisky to produce an incredibly smooth, complex and lighter style Old Fashioned.
As always, your choices are vital to the outcome of the recipe. From the quality of the maple syrup (yes, there is a difference in quality and it’s crazy how big the difference can be) to the choice of the Irish and American whisky you combine. It’s all vital to the success of this drink. If in doubt, check our recommendations for ideas.
The drink is combined together with water and bottled so it’s ready to pour straight from the bottle. Like any bottled recipe, if you can plan ahead and give the drink a few days or a week or so to mellow in the bottle, the end result will be even better!
8. Iron Goddess Old Fashioned
We developed this one for Woodford Reserve, and it’s probably the most ambitious sounding twist on the entire list. However, if you follow our step-by-step instructions, and have a little patience, you’ll be surprised just how easy this recipe is to make. It’s satisfying to make, delicious and dangerously easy to drink!
Many Old Fashioned recipes evoke the feelings and flavours of winter, but with peach liqueur as the ‘sugar’ and a little Aperol as the bitter, this is a bright and light take on the typical formula. Where it gets even more interesting is that the whiskey is infused with oolong tea then the entire drink is fat washed with milk to deliver a rich, velvety mouthfeel. The drink is filtered clear and bottled ready to be poured. This is one to impress your friends with.
9. Hyde’s Honey Old Fashioned
Written for our friend’s wedding, this is an elegantly simple twist on the classic Old Fashioned formula. It’s also a twist you can make your own by choosing a local honey that’s typical to your region, and influenced by the local flowers the bees visit.
The honey obviously replaces the sugar of a typical Old Fashioned, while chocolate bitters takes the place of aromatic bitters like Angostura. The traditional twist of orange remains to add brightness on the nose while the whisky is really up to you. We first made it with a Bourbon, but this is a truly malleable recipe, so pick your favourite tipple and get mixing.
10. Pancake Old Fashioned
Come on, you know you want to try this one. Pancakes, maple syrup, whisky! This one is a treat. Woodford Reserve bourbon is infused with pancakes to deliver a smooth, almost creamy cereal finish to the whisky. This is then stirred down with elegant, single estate maple syrup and a dash or two of orange bitters.
These flavours are so evocative, you can almost taste this recipe just from the description. To finish, along with the traditional orange twist, we recommend serving this version with a few pecans on the side to complete the experience.
Whisky Sour Family
The key elements of any sour is a famous trinity of ingredients; spirit, citrus and sugar. Every spirit base has a long list of famous ‘Sour Based’ cocktails, and whisky is no different.
All three of these twists on a whisky sour have this trinity of ingredients at their core, but they are then taken in very different directions. One is short and fruity, with a lovely dry nutty finish from Amotillado sherry. Another is long, crisp and refreshing, making use of honey and beer. Whilst the third is rich and fluffy with maple and apple to complement the whisky. As you would expect, all three recipes rely on perfectly balancing citrus and sugar, whilst at their core still sits the key ingredient, whisky!
11. Shell Street Shandy
Shandy, Panaché, Radler. These are all combinations of beer and a refreshing citrus soda, creating long, delicious low ABV cocktails. Shandy is likely the original, and would have first been made with ginger ale or beer, while the German Radler arose in 1922 and was followed some time later by the French Panaché.
Our version is a little stronger, somewhere between a Shandy, and a beer topped Whisky Collins. Irish whisky, honey and lemon are combined together to create a delicious little whisky sour. This is served long over ice then topped with ice cold frothy lager. Just add sunshine!
12. Artist’s Special Breakfast
Sometimes great drinks fall by the wayside because ingredients become unavailable or hard to come by. So it was with the Artist’s Special, a 1927 Parisien twist on the Whisky Sour.
We thought it was well worth bringing back, but to do so meant we had to tweak it to make the ingredients easier to find, whilst delivering a drink that was also delicious in its own right. The key, and most problematic ingredient was a redcurrant syrup called Groseille. In its place we decided on a rich blackcurrant preserve ( aka jam / jelly – depending where you’re from). The dark fruity flavours pair beautifully with the whisky, and the nutty notes of Amotillado sherry deliver a long dry finish for a perfectly balanced cocktail.
As this is a twist, not a recreation of the classic recipe, we also needed to change the name a little too. If you know the key ingredient in a Breakfast Martini…it should make sense.
13. Toffee Apple Whisky Sour
From cocktails to barbeque, whisky and maple has been a delicious and popular combination for a very long time. This take on the whisky sour balances the acidity of lemon juice with high quality maple syrup instead of sugar, adding more complexity and deeper richer flavour profile. Pressed apple complements all the flavours in the drink and, along with egg white (or your preferred foaming agent), produces a truly indulgent and fluffy mouthfeel.
Classic Twists on Classics You Must Try
These last three ‘bonus’ recipes weren’t written by us, they are classic whisky cocktails in their own right. However, they’re all also twists on even older classic whisky cocktails; the Whisky Sour, Mint Julep and Manhattan. Most importantly, they’re delicious, great drinks to add to your repertoire, and you should make them!
14. New York Sour
A Whisky Sour with a red wine float. Stunningly beautiful and a deliciously unique drinking experience.
15. Georgia Julep
The Mint Julep gets a Georgia makeover. Peach liqueur replaces sugar in this icy cold mint and whisky classic.
16. Rob Roy
A Sweet Manhattan, but make it with Scotch. Say no more…
We hope you’ve enjoyed our selection and it’s further opened your mind to the wide variety of whisky cocktails, and just how versatile whisky is as a cocktail ingredient.
While recipes are generally supposed to be made with a particular variety of Whisky, it’s important to remember that even within a specific category there’s huge variety in flavour profile. This flavour profile will of course impact on the character of the cocktail you’re making, so keep that in mind when picking your whisky.
To that point, these are generally robust recipes that will suit many, if not all, styles of Whisky. So if you only have one nice bottle of Whisky you’re mixing with, don’t be scared to try a recipe, even if you don’t have the exact style of whisky called for. You might decide it doesn’t suit a recipe here or there, alternatively you might think it works perfectly for what you like. I mean, is there a whisky brand out there that doesn’t have it’s own take on an Old Fashioned? I very much doubt it!
So don’t worry too much about what’s ‘correct’ and care more for what tastes great! You can always build up your whisky collection over time and then battle other cocktail nerds about what’s the ‘correct’ use of a whisky in a particular recipe. Or hopefully not… Cheers!
As always, don’t forget to show us what you made by tagging us!
@Candra_Drinks #MakeBetterDrinks #CandraDrinks