Search

Cocktail 101 : The Collins

Written by Seb  /  Edited by Natalia  /  Design by Andy

What can we say about this essential classic recipe? It’s boozy lemonade basically! Originally made with Gin (Tom Collins) the formula works with literally any spirit you enjoy drinking. It’s easy to twist and change into all sorts of variations through the addition of herbs, fruits, bitters or flavoured syrups.

The ‘Tom Collins’ is thought of as an American, more specifically, a New York classic. However, there is a less well known origin story from the early 1800s that could likely be the real origin of this recipe.

It involves a bartender / waiter named John Collin (yes Collin not Collins) and his dangerously delicious Limmer’s Punch, named after the bawdy, Dickensian London hotel of the same name.

Limmer’s hotel was on Conduit street by Hanover Square, and the bar or ‘Coffee House’ there was, by all accounts, a chaotic, dirty and lively sporting bar. With cock fighting, duels, gambling and plenty of drinking. In 1815 it was described as; “the evening resort for the sporting world.” It had bullet holes in the clock from drunken shooting competitions and a one legged porter / doorman called “Peg”. So, it sounds like you could have a lot of fun, assuming you didn’t die!

The hotel itself may be gone, but Limmer’s Punch and the stories of the hotel live on thanks to the writing of various visitors to the establishment. In Captain Rees Howell Gronow’s memoirs he described his first visit to Limmer’s in 1814, calling it “the most dirty hotel in London.”

We’re here to try and pick through the drinks history though, and more precisely John Collin’s famous Gin Punch. It was immortalized in writing in 1830 in a set of verses, some of which survived but are tricky to track down.

Lyrical Musings by Frank and Charles Sheridan –

“My name is John Collins, head waiter at Limmer’s,
Corner of Conduit Street, Hanover Square;
My chief occupation is filling of brimmers
For spicy young gentlemen frequenting there”

The punch that John Collin famously served was a simple take on a Gin Punch. Gin, lemon, water and Capillaire. It was likely originally made with still water, then evolved to use sparkling. Certainly nothing new or groundbreaking, but often that’s the point. It’s not always the first to do something, it’s the one who made it memorable that gets the credit. John Collin and the colourful stories of Limmer’s hotel are certainly memorable!

Looking forward, the only difference between this original recipe and the modern Tom Collins is the modern style dry gin and the use of Capillaire syrup to sweeten and balance the acidity of the lemon juice. Although early Capillaire recipes might include fern infused into it, by this time Capillaire was commonly made as a simple sugar syrup flavored with a splash of orange flower water.

So, essentially the ‘Limmer’s Punch’ is a large format ‘Tom Collins’ with a hint of orange flower water. As John Collin’s popular mixture became popular beyond the walls of the Limmer’s hotel the drink itself was being referred to as a ‘John Collins’ after the man himself. As the age of Punch started to come to an end, and Cocktail culture began to rise, recipes like the ‘John Collins’ would be downsized into the single serves we are more familiar with today.

Many claim that the ‘John Collins’ was first put into print in Haney’s, ‘The Steward and Barkeeper’s Manual’ of 1869. However, I’ve looked thoroughly through it and I can’t see it anywhere in there. Feel free to correct me if you can find any actual evidence of the recipe in there.

According to historian David Wondrich the first mention of a ‘John Collins’ in print was actually in a couple of different newspapers, found in both Canada and Australia. The recipe was still a large format gin punch lengthened with soda water.

By 1876 the Collins was immortalized in print in the 3rd edition of cocktail legend Jerry Thomas’ ‘Bartenders’ Guide’ and was already securing its place in New York cocktail culture as a long and refreshing single serve recipe.

The name was diverging between two different drinks. The ‘Tom Collins’, made with newly available and popular Old Tom Gin (a gin that had some sort of sweetening agent added to it), and the ‘John Collins’. Essentially the same drink but now made more commonly with Generver or Hollands Gin, the Dutch grain forward style of gin.

This is easy to confirm, simply flick to page 248 of Jerry Thomas’ ‘Bartenders’ Guide’ (3rd Edition) and you’ll find the below entries

Tom Collins Whiskey

(Use large bar glass.)

5 or 6 dashes of gum syrup.
Juice of a small lemon.
1 large wineglass of whiskey.
Fill the glass half full of shaved ice, shake up well and strain into a large bar glass.


Fill up the glass with plain soda water and imbibe
while it is lively.

Tom Collins Brandy.
The same as Tom Collins Whiskey, substituting brandy for whiskey.

Tom Collins Gin.
The same as Tom Collins Whiskey, substituting gin for whiskey.

Here ‘John’ is gone from the name and ‘Tom’ has taken over. In fact, ‘Tom’ has taken over all descriptors here. This perfectly shows the confusion and messiness with trying to tell the story of classic cocktails. The first Collins entry in a cocktail book and they are all called ‘Tom’, no ‘John’ but no mention of Old Tom gin.

Let’s look at a few of the other iconic cocktail books of the time and see if we can make more sense of it.

1882 Harry Johnson’s ‘New and Improved Bartender’s Manual’ we find a John Collins recipe using Genever or Holland’s Gin and a Tom Collins made with Old Tom Gin. Ok, so the story is back on track.

1905 Hoffman House Bartender’s Guide ‘John’ is missing but there is a recipe for a ‘Tom Collins’ using Old Tom Gin.

Let’s jump forward to 1930 and the legendary Savoy Cocktail Book by Harry Craddock and we still have a ‘John Collins’ recipe and it’s still using Hollands Gin. The Tom Collins is there too of course, but now we see gin’s future as the recipe moves from Old Tom to a Dry Gin, how the vast majority of Collins recipes are still made to this day.

Ingredients

Base Spirit of Choice

The original recipe is the ‘Tom Collins’ and uses Gin, but this recipe is so versatile, it will work with literally any spirit you like to drink.

Fresh Lemon Juice

Make sure it’s freshly squeezed, and for aesthetics purposes, we would recommend you strain it through a sieve to remove any pips or bits of flesh that will look unsightly floating around in the drink. 

Sugar

Bakers / Caster Sugar will work here as it’s fine enough to dissolve during shaking. However, for ease make yourself a Rich Simple Syrup and just keep it in the fridge for whenever you have an urge to mix cocktails!

Sparkling Water

As always, use something highly carbonated (with strong bubbles!).

As always, don’t forget to show us what you made by tagging us!
@Candra_Drinks  #MakeBetterDrinks  #CandraDrinks

Continue reading

Don’t Talk To Us About Garden Cocktails Until You’ve Tried These

We’re well into the season of summer hosting, blue skies, and competitive backyard barbecuing. While the cooler is likely already ...

Read More

Beyond the Pimm’s Cup: 5 Homemade Fruit Cup Recipes

The Pimm’s Cup is an undeniable icon of the English summer, but the world of Fruit Cups is incredibly versatile. ...

Read More

12 Best Maple Syrup Cocktails for Summer 2026

A great way to expand your cocktail canon this season is to master a single, versatile ingredient within classic templates. ...

Read More
Showing Slide 1 of 4

Get Cocktail Smart!

Join The Weekly Sip
Our Weekly Newsletter